My name is Mercurio Silver, and I don’t like… Dungeons and Dragons

My name is Mercurio Silver, and I don’t like… Dungeons and Dragons



[Mercurio Silver, gentleman critic. Discovered mining for quicklime in a quarry in the north of Somerset, Mercurio Silver used his sizeable fortune to fund The Reticule for three whole minutes. As a mark of gratitude we gave him his own article.]

I was introduced to Dungeons and Dragons a few years ago via the medium of Neverwinter Nights on the PC. Not a bad game, half-decent storyline and a lot of call to throw fireballs at people. Then again, I was younger and more stupid in those days. Even my youthful idiocy, however, could not save Dungeons and Dragons when I came to play the expansion packs.

You see, back at the start, I was of the opinion that Neverwinter Nights was largely acceptable. Yes, there were lizard people, the odd black/white moral choice and stupid quests, but you expect them in a fantasy game. Magic and stupid quests. So I forgave Neverwinter its dozy flaws, until Hordes of the Underdark.

This, the second expansion, gave me a window into what Dungeons and Dragons could be. Now, I have never played a pen and paper RPG in my life (because I have one), so I have never cracked open the ridiculously oversized “player’s manual” and sifted through all the rules and spreadsheets needed to craft a Dungeons and Dragons story. What I learned from Underdark was that the majority of this manual was probably a great big list of clichés for you to pick from.

This is how I would imagine a standard “campaign” (yes, I believe they call them that) would go, as following the rules set down in Underdark. Pay attention.

It is a dark and stormy night in a town whose name has too many vowels in it. You, a firmly established adventuring hero and sex symbol, are having a few drinks by the fire in a local tavern. The wenches are enjoying serving you, stuffing their tunics with leeks to make themselves appear even more buxom. You’re not complaining.

Just as you finish beating the third successive Dwarf in a drinking contest, the tavern doors are blown off their hinges by a magic spell! Evil has arrived! You scoop up your magic sword/ancient bow/knobbly wooden stick and charge into the fray.

You kill them all. Others are helping, sure, but they aren’t world renowned heroes that all the ladies love to swoon over, so you get the credit. You leave one alive, the one you know will be the most talkative. You can read people well, you’re a fantasy hero.

Half-dead villain sings like a canary then either dies or you kill him. Naturally, the evil villain needs you for an evil ritual to bring evil to the world and make it evil, and he lives in a cave or a mountain fortress. You kiss the wenches goodbye over a period of hours, then go searching for the evil villain.

Along the way, you bump into an evil race. Fantasy worlds are littered with races that are naturally evil, so you ready your magic sword/ancient bow/knobbly wooden stick and prepare to fight them. Out trots a scantily clad, almost illegally young member of the evil race. She flutters her eyelashes at you and says how this is a sect of good-evil race. You believe her.

You continue on your quest for a while, then good-evil race girl turns out to be evil-evil race girl after all. She stabs you in the back while you are shopping in the completely-at-home underground marketplace. You die and bump into Death.

You have a nice little chat, joke about playing chess for your life, have a beer or two, then he sends you back to your body with a get-out-of-death-free card. You are so famous even natural forces of the universe are your fans.

You wake up, avenge your death, save the world, attract thousands of women, blah blah blah.

I think you get the picture. Dungeons and Dragons is all about making you think you are a world famous person of godlike beauty, instead of an average looking fellow hunkered in a basement speaking in the third person about an elf you’ve scribbled on the back of a paper napkin.

Look, gentle reader, I understand I may be coming across as a little harsh, but I’m right.

After I played Neverwinter Nights, the world of Dungeons and Dragons started to converge on me, as though the game had made me a magnet for other players. I was forced to listen to them planning their campaigns, the infant-school Tolkien mixed with the above example, it was unbearable. They were the sort of people who would make up new rules, new classes, and enjoy balancing them.

I try not to do more than one example per article, I feel it runs the risk of actually detracting from my point, but I must make an exception here. This is a game that yabbers on about “D’s” and “rounds” and all that, yet there are people that will make rules just like this:

Sarcasm roll: When in conversation with a different race, any sarcastic dialogue is subject to a Sarcasm Roll. The player must roll 2d6, a d9, 4d3 and a d12, then add up the scores, remembering to include any modifiers (detailed below). If the total score exceeds the level of the other character, plus his/her age and sexual orientation, and his charisma roll, the sarcasm succeeds.

If you can understand that rule then you have a problem. In fact, you probably play Dungeons and Dragons on a regular basis, which will be the problem.

These new rules, do you know what they are? They are very nearly maths. Maths is not fun, you must remember that from school. The graph paper, quadratic equations, calculator tests, nowhere in there do I see “fun”.

It’s a small step from enjoying maths and making rules to the ultimate sin of Dungeons and Dragons. It is a sin I observed watching a cabal of rulesmiths, all of them male, playing female elves.

I speak, of course, of making rules regarding sex in a pen and paper RPG.

8 thoughts on “My name is Mercurio Silver, and I don’t like… Dungeons and Dragons

  1. The problem with DnD is that it wants to be a medium of collaborative storytelling but is instead stuck as a game for accountants, mathemeticians and lawyers (they’re the ones that know the all the rules backwards and all the loopholes). I used to play but then I found out about girls, going to the pub and soft drugs and the real world became alot more interesting. DnD is ok when you’re 12 (the same applies to collecting Warhammer miniatures) but when you start having to shave its time to put the dice away (though I do still have my Spacemarine Army, I put alot of work into it and I’m quite proud of it. go on, laugh).

  2. Hmm.

    I agree with this broadly; let that be said. I agree that some people are painful to watch playing that game. This is because Dungeons and Dragons isn’t a game with set rules, like a computer game. I mean, everyone’s tried to mess around with old board games and try weird rules, right? So yeah, the fact that it encourages you to explore your energy and be creative and get into the character is inviting a certain brand of arty-farty nonce.

    This is the bit where I say ‘However’. However! The newest incarnation of D&D isn’t really complicated, has big bright colours, and even points you to some online tools to make it all easier. It’s not a chore to play; it’s not even bogged down. You run into some monsters and roll a dice, which is an action soaked in social ostracism, and the dude with the book tells you if you hit him or not, and what happened to him.

    This is a gaming site, right? And you think D&D is bad for feeding your ego? Okay. I agree that, if a referee chooses to make the game easy or isn’t good with storytelling, you’re playing a buff dude competing with buff dudes for epic loot. That isn’t a D&D thing, not exclusively, not anymore; it’s just a type of game design. D&D’s weakness is that it’s designed my amateurs (non-professionals, not necessarily idiots) every time it’s played. It’s also cheap and is a pretty social activity, unlike tower defense.

    What you don’t like, sir, is what a bunch of people are doing, and therefore, those people. It’s like saying you hate WoW because you stumbled into an RP server, in the middle of a yaoi marriage or something. Jus’ sayin.

  3. To blame a set of rules for what people do with them seems silly. It’s like saying “I hate the GECK toolkit because people keep making these rubbish mods with it.”

    Oh and I can understand that rule and have never played D&D beyond Neverwinter (which I didn’t play for long as I just couldn’t get on with it). And thinking about it, do you not have to understand something before you can write it?

  4. Just to clarify: Mecurio Silver does not represent the opinions of the staff, and we don’t get copy approval of his articles. He’s a force of nature that can’t be stopped, and we’re all bloody terrified of him and his ridiculous walrus moustache (don’t tell him I said that). Please don’t anger him!

  5. The tabletop roleplaying experience is at it’s best when the rules and their adjudicator (GM, DM, Storyteller, Ancient-Dread-Lore-Master (listed in reverse order of social achievement)) cooperate with the players in order to bring out their inner improv acting talents. Its really useful that with the rules and dice (and enough hit location and damage result tables, if you’re in that deep) free the imagination of the players somewhat from the nitty and gritty of the “acting” to focus a little bit more on playing a “compelling” role. Or fun role. Or homage. Or parody. Or straight comic relief.
    If anyone walks away from the table, unable to retell the best event of the night in such a way as to make an uninvolved individual smile a bit and reply with their own- well, you’re doing it wrong and you need to try again until you get it right!

  6. I disagree completely. Sure there are some weird shit in P&P RPG’s but there is absolutely nothing wrong with them. They encourage strategy, puzzlesolving, creativity and more.

    And the thought that only really nerdy people who don’t go outside or talk to girls play DnD is completely untrue. There is an enormous amount of famous people who play such as:
    Stephen Colbert,
    Vin Diesel,
    Mike Myers,
    Dwayne Johnson AKA The Rock,
    Jon Stuart,
    evryone from Metalica,
    Stephen King,
    Hulk Hogan
    jack black
    conan obrien

    and about 90 other people… ( )

    You say math is not fun? That’s purly a subjective opinion which just tells me you sucked at math. Only people who suck at math think it’s no fun, I know a really preppy girl who spends most of her time out, and hates school, but her favorite subject is math.

    Math is barely used in dnd anyway, at most it’s adding and subtracting

  7. First of all, “Even in my youthful idiocy”, soeh, I suppose you’re stuck there? I don’t see a lot of mature sentences here at least.

    I’m not going to comment on this, but simply ask; Do you not have enough content in your life and instead go mock D&D?

    You know, a lot of stuff would be easier if people would learn to respect, accept and be happy for eachother – maybe you should think about that.
    Some people enjoy D&D, let them have their fun. If you don’t like it, it’s cool, just try see things from another perspective than your own; this might offend some people.
    I might think stuff about you, but I don’t say it aloud (yes I know I indirectly called you an idiot, but that was merely to get your attention), if I don’t have a motive, because if I don’t have a motive it won’t do any good?

    I feel you know where I’m going as you don’t seem like a complete screw up so please, don’t slaughter me now, just think of this post you made and these words

    Freedom of Speech is AWESOME! – but abusing it, sucks :(

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.